PHALIN THAKKAR · LEARNING MATERIAL

Worked solutions

Read these after making your own attempt. The deciding conditions matter as much as the final answer.

Foundation establishes the diagram, signs and calculation. Core practice combines ideas and conditions. Advanced extension adds parameters, stages, limiting cases or calculus. These are selected resources for JEE preparation, not a complete syllabus or an official difficulty classification.

Foundation

P1. Resolve the force

Prerequisites: Force components and vertical equilibrium

The actual forces are the pull, weight down and normal reaction up.

Fx=20cos⁡30∘=103≈17.3205 N,F_x=20\cos30^\circ=10\sqrt3\approx17.3205\ {\rm N},
Fy=20sin⁡30∘=10 N.F_y=20\sin30^\circ=10\ {\rm N}.

Vertical equilibrium gives N + 10 − 40 = 0, so N = 30 N.

ax=1034≈4.3301 m/s2.a_x=\frac{10\sqrt3}{4}\approx4.3301\ {\rm m/s^2}.

Check: N + Fy = mg. The horizontal and vertical components resolve the one applied force.

Return to P1 · Review your reasoning

Foundation

P2. Include kinetic friction

Prerequisites: P1; kinetic friction

Since the block slides right, friction points left:

fk=0.25(30)=7.50 N.f_k=0.25(30)=7.50\ {\rm N}.
ax=103−7.54≈2.4551 m/s2.a_x=\frac{10\sqrt3-7.5}{4}\approx2.4551\ {\rm m/s^2}.

The pull partly supports the block, so using μkmg would overestimate friction. The positive acceleration means the block speeds up in its current rightward motion.

Return to P2 · Review your reasoning

Core practice

P3. Check whether motion can begin

Prerequisites: P1 and P2; static friction as an inequality

During rest, N = 40 − F/2 and the required leftward static friction is F cos30°.

Rest is possible while:

Fcos⁡30∘≤0.50(40−F/2).F\cos30^\circ\le0.50(40-F/2).

The limiting force is:

Fcrit=20cos⁡30∘+0.25≈17.9207 N.F_{\rm crit} =\frac{20}{\cos30^\circ+0.25} \approx17.9207\ {\rm N}.

At exactly this value the block is at limiting equilibrium; motion begins when the applied force exceeds it.

For F = 12 N, N = 34 N. The required static friction is 6√3 ≈ 10.3923 N, less than its 17 N maximum. Its actual value is 10.3923 N leftward.

For F = 20 N, the required 17.3205 N exceeds the 15 N static maximum. Rightward sliding begins. Kinetic friction then becomes 7.50 N, giving ax ≈ 2.4551 m/s².

N first reaches zero at F = 80 N. At this boundary the surface is unloaded; for larger F the block accelerates upward and the contact equations must change.

Check: μsN is a maximum, not a value to assign at every force.

Return to P3 · Review your reasoning

Core practice

P4. Two different optimal angles

Prerequisites: P3; trigonometric identities and optimisation

At the threshold:

Fcrit(θ)=μsmgcos⁡θ+μssin⁡θ.F_{\rm crit}(\theta)=\frac{\mu_smg}{\cos\theta+\mu_s\sin\theta}.

The denominator can be written:

1+μs2cos⁡(θ−tan⁡−1μs).\sqrt{1+\mu_s^2}\cos(\theta-\tan^{-1}\mu_s).

It is largest at θ = tan⁻¹μs, so:

θstart≈26.5651∘,Fmin⁡=201.25=85≈17.8885 N.\theta_{\rm start}\approx26.5651^\circ,\qquad F_{\min}=\frac{20}{\sqrt{1.25}} =8\sqrt5\approx17.8885\ {\rm N}.

For rightward sliding:

ax(θ)=F(cos⁡θ+μksin⁡θ)−μkmgm.a_x(\theta)=\frac{F(\cos\theta+\mu_k\sin\theta)-\mu_kmg}{m}.

Its maximum is at θ = tan⁻¹μk ≈ 14.0362°:

amax⁡=201.0625−104=517−104≈2.6539 m/s2.a_{\max} =\frac{20\sqrt{1.0625}-10}{4} =\frac{5\sqrt{17}-10}{4} \approx2.6539\ {\rm m/s^2}.

Both have N > 0. The first optimum concerns limiting static friction; the second concerns kinetic friction during an existing motion.

Check: the best angle is not necessarily the angle giving the largest horizontal component alone.

Return to P4 · Review your reasoning

Core practice

P5. When the surface stops supporting the block

Prerequisites: P1; unilateral contact and Newton’s second law

At the contact boundary:

20−30sin⁡θc=0,θc=sin⁡−1(2/3)≈41.8103∘.20-30\sin\theta_c=0,\qquad \theta_c=\sin^{-1}(2/3)\approx41.8103^\circ.

At 60° the upward component exceeds the weight. The block leaves the surface, so N = 0:

ax=30cos⁡60∘2=7.50 m/s2,a_x=\frac{30\cos60^\circ}{2}=7.50\ {\rm m/s^2},
ay=30sin⁡60∘−202≈2.9904 m/s2.a_y=\frac{30\sin60^\circ-20}{2} \approx2.9904\ {\rm m/s^2}.

A negative normal reaction would require the floor to attract the block. It signals that the assumed contact model has ceased to apply.

Return to P5 · Review your reasoning

Core practice

P6. Two blocks and a slipping condition

Prerequisites: P2 and P3; separate free body diagrams

The floor reaction is (1 + 3)g = 40 N, so floor friction is 8 N leftward.

If both blocks move together:

a=F−84.a=\frac{F-8}{4}.

For F = 24 N, a = 4 m/s². The upper block requires 4 N of rightward friction. The equal and opposite contact friction on the lower block is leftward.

The upper block’s maximum static friction is 0.50 × 1 × 10 = 5 N. Hence a ≤ 5 m/s²:

F≤28 N.F\le28\ {\rm N}.

With F = 32 N, relative sliding begins. Interface kinetic friction has magnitude 0.30 × 10 = 3 N:

aupper=3.00 m/s2,a_{\rm upper}=3.00\ {\rm m/s^2},
alower=32−8−33=7.00 m/s2.a_{\rm lower}=\frac{32-8-3}{3}=7.00\ {\rm m/s^2}.

The lower block accelerates faster, consistent with the assumed relative slipping direction.

Return to P6 · Review your reasoning

Advanced extension

P7. A spring with friction

Prerequisites: Work and energy; spring force; static and kinetic friction

Initially the spring pulls right with k(0.40) = 20 N, exceeding the 3 N static maximum. Motion begins.

While the block moves right, kinetic friction is 2 N leftward. At its first turning point x > 0:

12k(0.40)2=12kx2+2(0.40+x).\frac12k(0.40)^2 =\frac12kx^2+2(0.40+x).

Thus 25x² + 2x − 3.2 = 0. The physically relevant root is x = +0.32 m.

During the first rightward motion:

12v2=4−25x2−2(x+0.40).\frac12v^2=4-25x^2-2(x+0.40).

Speed is largest where the rightward net force vanishes:

−50x−2=0,x=−0.04 m.-50x-2=0,\qquad x=-0.04\ {\rm m}.

The kinetic energy there is 3.24 J, so:

vmax⁡=6.48≈2.5456 m/s.v_{\max}=\sqrt{6.48}\approx2.5456\ {\rm m/s}.

At x = +0.32 m, the spring pulls left with 16 N. Static friction can provide at most 3 N, so the block reverses.

For successive turning amplitudes A and B, energy loss over distance A + B gives:

12k(A2−B2)=2(A+B),\frac12k(A^2-B^2)=2(A+B),

so A − B = 2(2)/50 = 0.08 m. The turning positions are:

−0.40, +0.32, −0.24, +0.16, −0.08, 0 m.

At every nonzero turning point the spring exceeds the 3 N static limit. At x = 0 it has no force and remains at rest.

Check: maximum speed occurs before the relaxed position because friction also acts there.

Return to P7 · Review your reasoning

Advanced extension

P8. Energy and contact in a vertical loop

Prerequisites: Work and energy; radial acceleration; contact

Crossing the rough section dissipates μkmgL. The loop entry speed satisfies:

vb2=2g(H−μkL).v_b^2=2g(H-\mu_kL).

At the top, energy gives vt² = vb² − 4gR. Contact requires vt² ≥ gR. Therefore:

Hmin⁡=μkL+52R=0.20+1.25=1.45 m.H_{\min}=\mu_kL+\frac52R=0.20+1.25=1.45\ {\rm m}.

At that height vb² = 5gR. The bottom reaction is:

Nb=m(vb2/R+g)=6mg.N_b=m(v_b^2/R+g)=6mg.

For a general angle θ from the bottom:

v2=2g[H−μkL−R(1−cos⁡θ)],v^2=2g[H-\mu_kL-R(1-\cos\theta)],
N=m(v2R+gcos⁡θ)=mg[2(H−μkL)R−2+3cos⁡θ]N=m\left(\frac{v^2}{R}+g\cos\theta\right)=mg\left[\frac{2(H-\mu_k L)}{R}-2+3\cos\theta\right]

For H = 1.20 m, set N = 0:

cos⁡θ=−23,θ≈131.8103∘.\cos\theta=-\frac23,\qquad \theta\approx131.8103^\circ.

The speed is still positive:

v2=−gRcos⁡θ=103,v≈1.8257 m/s.v^2=-gR\cos\theta=\frac{10}{3},\qquad v\approx1.8257\ {\rm m/s}.

It therefore loses contact before reversing on the track.

Correct statements: A, B and D.

Check: energy determines the available speed; the normal reaction determines whether the prescribed circular path is physically possible.

Return to P8 · Review your reasoning

Foundation

M1. Roots and intervals

Prerequisites: Factorisation and signs

(a) (x − 3)(x − 4) ≤ 0 gives [3, 4].

(b) (x + 3)(x − 2) > 0 gives (−∞, −3) ∪ (2, ∞).

(c) Multiplying by −1 reverses the inequality. Then (x − 1)(x − 3) ≥ 0 gives (−∞, 1] ∪ [3, ∞).

Check one point inside and outside each pair of roots. Use brackets only where equality is permitted.

Return to M1 · Review your reasoning

Core practice

M2. A rational inequality with a repeated root

Prerequisites: M1; rational domains and repeated roots

The domain excludes x = −1 and x = 2.

The squared factor is positive except at x = 1, where it is zero. Away from that point, the sign follows:

x−4(x−2)(x+1).\frac{x-4}{(x-2)(x+1)}.

The signs on the intervals separated by −1, 1, 2 and 4 are:

Interval Sign

x < −1 Negative

−1 < x < 1 Positive

1 < x < 2 Positive

2 < x < 4 Negative

x > 4 Positive

Include x = 1 as an isolated zero and x = 4 as an allowed endpoint. The answer is:

(−∞,−1)∪{1}∪(2,4].(-\infty,-1)\cup\{1\}\cup(2,4].

Check: cancelling the squared factor without separately keeping x = 1 would lose a valid solution.

Return to M2 · Review your reasoning

Advanced extension

M3. A quadratic for every real x

Prerequisites: M1; discriminant and degenerate cases

If a < 1, the quadratic opens downward and becomes negative for large |x|.

If a = 1, the expression is −2x + 4, which also fails for all real x.

For a > 1, require a nonpositive discriminant:

Δ=4a2−4(a−1)(a+3)=4(3−2a)≤0.\Delta=4a^2-4(a-1)(a+3)=4(3-2a)\le0.

Thus:

a≥32.a\ge\frac32.

At a = 3/2 the expression is ½(x − 3)², so equality is valid.

Check: the discriminant condition was used only after verifying a positive leading coefficient.

Return to M3 · Review your reasoning

Core practice

M4. An absolute value inequality

Prerequisites: M1; absolute values and intersections

The right side must satisfy x + 1 ≥ 0.

The absolute value condition is equivalent to:

x2−5x+2≤0,x^2-5x+2\le0,

and:

x2−3x+4≥0.x^2-3x+4\ge0.

The second expression is always positive because it opens upward and has discriminant −7. The first is nonpositive between its roots:

5−172≤x≤5+172.\boxed{\frac{5-\sqrt{17}}2\le x\le\frac{5+\sqrt{17}}2}.

This interval already has x > −1, so the right side condition is satisfied.

Check: squaring without checking signs can introduce extraneous solutions.

Return to M4 · Review your reasoning

Advanced extension

M5. Roots inside a particular interval

Prerequisites: M3; vertex and endpoint values

For a convex quadratic to have two distinct roots inside (0, 3), its minimum must be inside that interval and below zero, with positive values at both endpoints.

The vertex is x = k. The discriminant is:

Δ=4(k−2)(k+1)>0.\Delta=4(k-2)(k+1)>0.

Together with 0 < k < 3 this gives k > 2.

At x = 0 the value k + 2 is positive. At x = 3:

11−5k>0⇒k<115.11-5k>0\quad\Rightarrow\quad k<\frac{11}{5}.

Therefore:

2<k<115.2<k<\frac{11}{5}.

At k = 2 the roots merge. At k = 11/5 one root is 3. Both boundaries must be excluded.

Return to M5 · Review your reasoning

Advanced extension

M6. A logarithm with a variable base

Prerequisites: M2; logarithm domains and monotonicity

The domain is x > 1 with x ≠ 2. The argument is always positive:

x2−5x+7=(x−2.5)2+0.75.x^2-5x+7=(x-2.5)^2+0.75.

For 1 < x < 2 the base is between 0 and 1, so:

x2−5x+7≤x−1⇒(x−2)(x−4)≤0.x^2-5x+7\le x-1 \quad\Rightarrow\quad (x-2)(x-4)\le0.

Its solution [2, 4] has no overlap with (1, 2).

For x > 2, the base exceeds 1:

x2−5x+7≥x−1⇒(x−2)(x−4)≥0.x^2-5x+7\ge x-1 \quad\Rightarrow\quad (x-2)(x-4)\ge0.

Intersecting with x > 2 gives:

x∈[4,∞).x\in[4,\infty).

Check: at x = 4 the logarithm is log₃3 = 1.

Return to M6 · Review your reasoning

Advanced extension

M7. Nonnegative on a restricted interval

Prerequisites: M3; minimum on a closed interval

For a ≤ 0, the vertex is at or left of the interval. The minimum on [0, 2] is at x = 0 and equals a + 1. These values work exactly when −1 ≤ a ≤ 0.

For 0 < a < 2, the vertex lies inside the interval. Its value is:

a+1−a2.a+1-a^2.

It is nonnegative for:

0<a≤1+52.0<a\le\frac{1+\sqrt5}{2}.

For a ≥ 2, the minimum occurs at x = 2, where 5 − 3a < 0. These values fail.

Therefore:

a∈[−1,1+52].a\in\left[-1,\frac{1+\sqrt5}{2}\right].

At a = −1 the expression is x(x + 2), which is nonnegative on [0, 2] even though it has real roots and takes negative values outside that interval. At the upper boundary it is a perfect square.

Requiring a nonpositive discriminant would incorrectly exclude −1 ≤ a < (1 − √5)/2. Roots and negative values outside the requested interval need not invalidate the condition.

Return to M7 · Review your reasoning

Advanced extension

M8. Derivatives and the number of roots

Prerequisites: Derivatives, stationary values and root counting

The derivative is:

fa′(x)=3(x2−a).f_a'(x)=3(x^2-a).

For a < 0 it is positive everywhere. For a = 0 it vanishes only at x = 0 and the cubic remains strictly increasing. For a > 0 it is negative between −√a and √a.

Answer to (a): a ≤ 0.

For a > 0 the stationary values are:

fa(−a)=2+2a3/2>0,f_a(-\sqrt a)=2+2a^{3/2}>0,
fa(a)=2−2a3/2.f_a(\sqrt a)=2-2a^{3/2}.

Three distinct roots require the local maximum to be positive and the local minimum negative. Hence:

a>1.a>1.

To put all three inside (−3, 3), require the two stationary points inside the interval, f(−3) < 0 and f(3) > 0.

f(−3)=9a−25,f(3)=29−9a.f(-3)=9a-25,\qquad f(3)=29-9a.

The stricter bound is a < 25/9. With a > 1 this also places the stationary points inside (−3, 3). Thus:

1<a<259.1<a<\frac{25}{9}.

At a = 1:

x3−3x+2=(x−1)2(x+2).x^3-3x+2=(x-1)^2(x+2).

There are two distinct real roots, one repeated. At a = 25/9 one root reaches −3.

Check: a derivative equal to zero at one point does not by itself prevent strict increase or guarantee an extremum.

Return to M8 · Review your reasoning